Picture this: You’re in your stylist’s chair, unsure which protective style to choose. There’s no shortage of options, and some might seem quite similar. Take knotless braids and box braids, for example. Both styles offer unique benefits and looks, but are sometimes mixed up. Understanding their differences can help you choose the braids that best fit your lifestyle and haircare needs. Let's dive into each style below, so when you find yourself at the salon, you’ll know exactly what to ask for.
What Are Box Braids?
Box braids are a popular protective hairstyle featuring individual plaits that are divided into square-shaped sections. This style can be created using natural hair or with the addition of extensions (referred to as braiding hair) for extra length and volume. Box braids are known for their versatility, durability, and low maintenance, making them a favorite choice for many.
When installing box braids, the braiding specialist will part the hair into small box-like sections, applying braiding gel to each part to assist with gripping and creating neat parts. Then, they begin braiding the hair, incorporating extensions if desired. When adding extensions, the braider typically starts by securing them with a knot at the scalp to help with longevity.
Good hair day by @shuggthestylist.
What Are Knotless Braids?
Knotless braids are a modern variation of traditional box braids. The trendy hairstyle features individual plaits that start with natural hair and gradually incorporate extensions. This technique doesn’t require creating a knot at the base of the braid, which helps with achieving a smoother, flatter appearance and creates less tension on the scalp. Knotless braids are celebrated for their natural look (they mimic the look of natural hair growth), comfort, and reduced risk of hair breakage, making them an increasingly popular choice for protective styling.
What Is the Difference Between Knotless Braids and Box Braids?
The difference between knotless braids and box braids is the technique used to install them. Knotless braids start with natural hair, and extensions are gradually added without a knot, resulting in a more seamless look. Box braids begin with a knot at the root, creating a defined, structured appearance. Both styles have their unique benefits and aesthetic appeal.
What Lasts Longer: Box Braids vs. Knotless?
How long a style lasts is often a consideration when choosing between different protective hairstyles due to the time and money invested in the service. Knotless braids typically last around 4-6 weeks with proper care. Since these braids do not have knots at the base, they are more prone to frizz, and regular maintenance is necessary to keep them looking fresh. Traditional box braids generally last longer than knotless braids, often up to 8 weeks or more with proper care. The thicker base and more secure knotting technique contribute to their longevity.
Box Braids vs. Knotless: Which Is Right For You?
Both box braids and knotless braids have their own set of benefits and considerations. To determine which braided style is right for you, you’ll need to consider your current haircare regimen, lifestyle, and how much maintenance you can commit to.
What are the benefits of box braids?
- Durable: Box braids are known for their longevity and ability to withstand more manipulation and environmental factors than knotless braids.
- Less Time To Install: Don’t like sitting too long? Box braids appointments are usually shorter than knotless braids appointments.
- More Affordable: Box braids tend to be cheaper than knotless braids since they take less time to install.
- Versatile Styling: You can style box braids in various ways, including updos, ponytails, and intricate patterns.
- Low Maintenance: Once installed, box braids require minimal daily upkeep, making them an ideal choice for those with busy lifestyles.
What are the benefits of knotless braids?
- Natural Look: Since knotless braids start with your natural hair at the root, it tends to be less evident that you’re wearing extensions.
- Less Tension: Knotless braids are the best choice if you have a sensitive scalp or prefer a style with less tension after installation.
- Reduced Breakage: The tension-free installation of knotless braids reduces the risk of hair breakage and scalp irritation.
- Flexibility and Versatility: The gradual addition of extensions makes knotless braids more flexible and less stiff, allowing for easier styling and movement. It’s also easy to switch-up your style without discomfort.
- Easier Removal: Knotless braids are generally easier and quicker to take out compared to traditional box braids.
Good hair day by @desiraymershani.
How To Care For Box Braids
Even with the most low-maintenance hairstyles, it’s essential to properly care for your natural hair. You'll need a good routine and products to keep your box braids looking fresh. Follow these three tips:
Keep your scalp clean and moisturized
Haircare starts at the scalp. On wash day, shampoo with the Mizani Moisture Fusion Gentle Clarifying Shampoo to remove buildup—the gentle formula helps refresh your hair and is great for all hair textures and curl types. Follow it up by massaging the Mizani Scalp Care Calming Lotion onto your scalp. The leave-in treatment helps moisturize and soothe.
Protect your edges
When installing your braids, let your braiding specialist know if they are too tight around your edges. Avoiding excessive tension will help prevent hair loss and breakage.
Wrap your hair at night
Wear a satin scarf or bonnet to protect your braids while sleeping. It will help maintain your style and prevent frizz. In fact, this is a great haircare tip for just about any protective hairstyle.
Good hair day by @theindiahoward.
How To Care For Knotless Braids
Caring for knotless braids is comparable to caring for traditional box braids. Again, you’ll want to curate a routine with the right products. Here’s what we recommend:
Keep your scalp clean and moisturized
Cleanse your scalp with a pre-cleanser like the Mizani Wonder Crown Foaming Pre-Cleanser. The nozzle allows you to apply the formula—which helps remove buildup without stripping away essential oils—directly to your scalp. After, use a clarifying shampoo for a deeper clean. You’ll also want to moisturize your scalp regularly with a lightweight oil or scalp spray. Try the Mizani 25 Miracle Nourishing Hair Oil to help fight frizz and make your hair more manageable.
Book a touch-up service
As we mentioned, knotless braids typically don’t last as long as box braids. To keep your style looking neat, schedule touch-up services as needed with your braiding specialist. They can refresh the first 2-3 rows to prolong the life of your braids.
Wear a satin scarf at night
As you unwind at the end of the day, remember to wear a satin scarf or bonnet to protect your braids while you sleep. Your morning self will thank you when you wake up with frizz-free braids and can start your day looking good.
Next Up: 50 Easy Natural Hairstyles To Try in 2024
For customized braiding advice, use our salon locator to book an appointment with a stylist near you.
Header photo credits (left to right): @shuggthestylist and @hannahh_lu
